applicability of bourdieu's field theory in iranian modern architecture (notes on pierre bourdieu’s sociology of art)
نویسندگان
چکیده
entangled with their historical and cultural contexts, sociological theories come into existence and try to explain social phenomena of their own society. hence, practitioners of other milieus with different accumulation of cultural traits must be aware of how they use non-native theories. a wide range of iranian sociological investigations, unfortunately, take benefit of western social scientific theories to explain particular social facts of an entirely different context regardless of significant differences. ten years after his death, bourdieu’s field theory is so much well-known in iran that might be used everywhere whether correctly or in a wrong place. it is not acceptable to apply european scientific theories including bourdieu’s elements of sociology of art with no contextual consideration. it must be noticed that spatial realm, i.e., context of a theory while applying is highly important. furthermore, every theory requires some revisions while facing different subjects of study. therefore in this article under two topics; contexts of generation is different from the context of application and essential differences between subject matters, i try to illustrate that every theory coming into existence in its unique socio-cultural context to explain specific realm of subjects, needs to be reconsidered in order to qualify a capability to describe and explain both social fact of a different society and a different analytical sphere. regarding iranian traditional architecture as a prominent artistic aspect of pre-modern iran and a controversial field onward, i note some points basically necessary for the application of bourdieu's field theory and sociology of art in a different context. structural homology, for instance, is a concept needed to be considered due to the fact that in the case of architecture, it is hardly possible to find a mirror reflexion between structural position of the creator and the hero created by him. this is because architecture is essentially different from novel or other literary text. there exists no action, no social order, and no circulation in a building. on the other side, the french context inside which bourdieu commenced to theorise his reflections seem totally different from iranian context in which his theory is going to be applied. social prestige besides class status, for instance, are two honourable achievements gained through cultural consumerism in french society. therefore, in the aforementioned context, the challenge among different classes takes over soft products such as cultural tastes such as music, theatre, dance, sport, food, clothe, and etc., while on the contrary economic achievements such as car, house, land, villa, and international trips are the representations over which actors of iranian context still challenge one another and try to show off. in this case, there is a great difference to which a practitioner must pay attention otherwise he cannot distinguish function of this theory in its original cultural source from the non-native destination. in the end i conclude that bourdieu’s field theory such as other european sociological theories is competent to help us observe, scientifically, our social surrounding under a condition that some revisions and reconsiderations must be carried on to enlarge its borders.
منابع مشابه
the effect of learning strategies on the speaking ability of iranian students in the context of language institutes
the effect of learning strategies on the speaking ability of iranian students in the context of language institutes abstract language learning strategies are of the most important factors that help language learners to learn a foreign language and how they can deal with the four language skills specifically speaking skill effectively. acknowledging the great impact of learning strategies...
an investigation on influencing factors on tourists shopping attitude of iranian handmade carpet in isfahan
چکیده ندارد.
15 صفحه اولthe tragedy of modern man in arthur millers world
what miller wants is a theatre of heightened consciousness. he speaks of two passions in a man, the passion to "feel" and the passion "know". he belives that we can have more of the latter. he says: drama is akin to the other inventions of man in that it ought to help us know more and not merely to spend our feelings. the writing of the crucible shows us that he is trying to give more heightene...
15 صفحه اولon translation of politeness strategies in dialogues involving female characters in translations and retranslations of novels translated before and after the islamic revolution of iran and their effects on the image of women: a polysystem theory approach
abstract reception environment has considerable effects on accepting a translation. as the expectations of a target culture and its values and needs change throughout history, its criteria for accepting a translation or rejecting it will change accordingly (gentzler, 2001). the expectations of iran, as the reception environment in the present study, have changed after the islamic revolution. i...
focus on communication in iranian high school language classes: a study of the role of teaching materials in changing the focus onto communication in language classes
چکیده ارتباط در کلاس به عوامل زیادی از جمله معلمان، دانش آموزان، برنامه های درسی و از همه مهم تر، مواد آموزشی وابسته است. در تدریس ارتباطی زبان که تاکید زیادی بر توانش ارتباطی دارد، کتاب درسی به عنوان عامل موثر بر پویایی کلاس محسوب میگردد که درس ها را از طریق فراهم آوردن متن ارتباط کلاسی و هم چنین نوع تمرین زبانی که دانش آموزان در طول فعالیت های کلاسی به آن مشغول اند، کنترل می کند. این حقیقت ک...
15 صفحه اولthe effect of consciousness raising of sociolinguistic skills on speaking ability of iranian efl learners
abstract the main purpose of this study was to investigate whether there was any significant difference between the speaking achievement of learners who were trained by means of consciousness raising of sociolinguistic skills and that of learners who were trained without the above mentioned task. the participants of this study consist of 60 intermediate level students participating languag...
منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
جامعه شناسی هنر و ادبیاتجلد ۵، شماره ۲، صفحات ۲۴۱-۲۵۷
کلمات کلیدی
میزبانی شده توسط پلتفرم ابری doprax.com
copyright © 2015-2023